Rookie of the Year
| Year | Team | Player | ||
| 2042 | Detroit Lions | HB Brian Robinson | ||
| 2041 | Detroit Lions | QB Eric Barriere | ||
| 2040 | Los Angeles Chargers | HB Khalil Herbert | ||
| 2039 | Kansas City Chiefs | QB Justin Fields | ||
| 2038 | Detroit Lions | QB Tua Tagovailoa | ||
| 2037 | Chicago Cardinals | K Justin Rohrwasser | ||
| 2036 | Oakland Raiders | K Matt McCrane | ||
| 2035 | Detroit Lions | QB Dwayne Haskins | ||
| 2034 | Chicago Cardinals | QB Sam Darnold | ||
| 2033 | Chicago Cardinals | WR Dylan Cantrell | ||
| 2032 | San Diego Chargers | HB Samaje Perine | ||
| 2031 | Tennessee Titans | QB Joshua Dobbs | ||
| 2030 | Green Bay Packers | WR Laquon Treadwell | ||
| 2029 | Chicago Bears | K Roberto Aguayo | ||
| 2028 | New York Giants | K Sam Ficken | ||
| 2027 | Houston Oilers | K Justin Mantin | ||
| 2026 | Chicago Bears | K Cairo Santos | ||
| 2025 | Detroit Lions | QB Tom Savage | ||
| 2024 | Indianapolis Colts | QB Matt Barkley | ||
| 2023 | Washington Redskins | QB Tyler Bray | ||
| 2022 | Arizona Cardinals | K John Potter | ||
| 2021 | New England Patriots | QB Andrew Luck | ||
| 2020 | San Francisco 49ers | QB Andy Dalton | ||
| 2019 | New England Patriots | QB Jake Locker | ||
| 2018 | San Francisco 49ers | HB Montario Hardestry | ||
| 2017 | Indianapolis Colts | K Aaron Pettrey | ||
| 2016 | Detroit Lions | QB Mark Sanchez | ||
| 2015 | Washington Redskins | QB Mathew Stafford | ||
| 2014 | New York Jets | QB Matt Ryan | ||
| 2013 | San Francisco 49ers | K Bill Rolfe | ||
| 2012 | Tampa Bay Bucs | K Darrell Lucas | ||
| 2011 | Houston Oilers | WR Derek Hagan | ||
| 2010 | Buffalo Bills | QB Matt Leinart | ||
| 2009 | Atlanta Falcons | K Jon Spencer | ||
| 2008 | Pittsburgh Steelers | WR Troy Williamson | ||
| 2007 | Chicago Bears | K Greg Gailbraith | ||
| 2006 | New York Jets | WR Rashaun Woods | ||
| 2005 | Philadelphia Eagles | QB Carson Palmer | ||
| 2004 | Buffalo Bills | WR Josh Reed | ||
| 2003 | San Diego Chargers | K Jamie Rheem | ||
| 2002 | New York Giants | QB Don Youngblood | ||
| 2001 | Atlanta Falcons | HB Thomas Jones | ||
| 2000 | Detroit Lions | QB Bernie Mitchell | ||
| 1999 | Baltimore Colts | HB Kevin Faulk | ||
| 1998 | Detroit Lions | QB Charlie Batch | ||