| Year | Bowl | Date | AFC Champion | NFC Champion | Super Bowl Champions | Super Bowl MVP | ||||
| 2043 | XLVI | 1/28/2024 | Kansas City Chiefs | 21 | Chicago Cardinals | 31 | Chicago Cardinals | Cardinals QB Sam Darnold | ||
| 2042 | XLV | 7/30/2023 | New York Jets | 22 | Chicago Cardinals | 10 | New York Jets | Jets QB Mac Jones | ||
| 2041 | XLIV | 2/5/2023 | Los Angeles Chargers | 35 | Atlanta Falcons | 17 | Los Angeles Chargers | Chargers S Amani Hooker | ||
| 2040 | XLIII | 8/7/2022 | New York Jets | 39 | Chicago Cardinals | 14 | New York Jets | Jets QB Derek Carr | ||
| 2039 | XLII | 2/6/2022 | New York Jets | 17 | Washington Redskins | 9 | New York Jets | Jets QB Derek Carr | ||
| 2038 | XLI | 8/1/2021 | New York Jets | 20 | Chicago Cardinals | 21 | Chicago Cardinals | Jets HB Dexter Williams | ||
| 2037 | XL | 1/24/2021 | New York Jets | 33 | Carolina Panthers | 6 | New York Jets | Jets QB Derek Carr | ||
| 2036 | XXXIX | 7/18/2020 | Denver Broncos | 17 | Washington Redskins | 31 | Washington Redskins | Redskins QB Blake Bortles | ||
| 2035 | XXXVIII | 1/12/2020 | New York Jets | 23 | New York Giants | 24 | New York Giants | Giants QB Jake Locker | ||
| 2034 | XXXVII | 7/7/2019 | New York Jets | 21 | Washington Redskins | 16 | New York Jets | Jets HB Eddie Lacy | ||
| 2033 | XXXVI | 12/23/2018 | New York Jets | 31 | New York Giants | 17 | New York Jets | Jets QB Derek Carr | ||
| 2032 | XXXV | 6/17/2018 | New York Jets | 28 | New York Giants | 31 | New York Giants | Jets WR Jeff Godfrey | ||
| 2031 | XXXIV | 12/10/2017 | San Diego Chargers | 13 | San Francisco 49ers | 10 | San Diego Chargers | Chargers CB Lamarcus Joyner | ||
| 2030 | XXXIII | 6/4/2017 | San Diego Chargers | 28 | New York Giants | 40 | New York Giants | Giants QB Jake Locker | ||
| 2029 | XXXII | 12/4/2016 | Houston Oilers | 42 | New York Giants | 24 | Houston Oilers | Oilers QB Andrew Luck | ||
| 2028 | XXXI | 5/15/2016 | Pittsburgh Steelers | 7 | New York Giants | 52 | New York Giants | Giants QB Jake Locker | ||
| 2027 | XXX | 11/22/2015 | Houston Oilers | 21 | New York Giants | 13 | Houston Oilers | Oilers HB Joseph Randle | ||
| 2026 | XXIX | 6/7/2015 | Houston Oilers | 17 | Chicago Bears | 7 | Houston Oilers | Oilers HB Roy Helu | ||
| 2025 | XXVIII | 12/14/2014 | New England Patriots | 13 | New York Giants | 20 | New York Giants | Giants HB David Wilson | ||
| 2024 | XXVII | 6/29/2014 | Miami Dolphins | 27 | Chicago Bears | 8 | Miami Dolphins | Dolphins QB Andrew Luck | ||
| 2023 | XXVI | 1/5/2014 | Miami Dolphins | 41 | New York Giants | 16 | Miami Dolphins | Dolphins QB Andrew Luck | ||
| 2022 | XXV | 6/30/2013 | Miami Dolphins | 17 | Tampa Bay Bucs | 23 | Tampa Bay Bucs | Bucs QB Sam Bradford | ||
| 2021 | XXIV | 1/6/2013 | Miami Dolphins | 43 | New York Giants | 13 | Miami Dolphins | Dolphins WR Santonio Holmes | ||
| 2020 | XXIII | 7/8/2012 | New York Jets | 13 | New York Giants | 26 | New York Giants | Giants QB Jake Locker | ||
| 2019 | XXII | 1/15/2012 | Buffalo Bills | 27 | Jacksonville Jaguars | 19 | Buffalo Bills | Bills QB Chad Henne | ||
| 2018 | XXI | 7/17/2011 | Buffalo Bills | 24 | San Francisco 49ers | 6 | Buffalo Bills | Bills QB Chad Henne | ||
| 2017 | XX | 1/2/2011 | Buffalo Bills | 48 | Tampa Bay Bucs | 9 | Buffalo Bills | Bills QB Chad Henne | ||
| 2016 | XIX | 6/13/2010 | San Diego Chargers | 24 | San Francisco 49ers | 21 | San Diego Chargers | Chargers QB Brian Brohm | ||
| 2015 | XVIII | 12/19/2009 | Buffalo Bills | 34 | New York Giants | 6 | Buffalo Bills | Bills HB North Stucky | ||
| 2014 | XVII | 6/14/2009 | Buffalo Bills | 26 | New York Giants | 0 | Buffalo Bills | Bills QB Matt Leinart | ||
| 2013 | XVI | 1/4/2009 | Buffalo Bills | 18 | Detroit Lions | 21 | Detroit Lions | Lions S Keith Morgan | ||
| 2012 | XV | 5/24/2008 | New England Patriots | 3 | Dallas Cowboys | 30 | Dallas Cowboys | Cowboys LB Samson Sherod | ||
| 2011 | XIV | 10/14/2007 | Baltimore Colts | 21 | San Francisco 49ers | 13 | Baltimore Colts | Colts DE Courtney Brown | ||
| 2010 | XIII | 3/18/2007 | Denver Broncos | 29 | Dallas Cowboys | 39 | Dallas Cowboys | Cowboys WR Santana Moss | ||
| 2009 | XII | 7/30/2006 | Baltimore Colts | 49 | Green Bay Packers | 34 | Baltimore Colts | Colts QB Rex Grossman | ||
| 2008 | XI | 12/26/2005 | Oakland Raiders | 24 | Atlanta Falcons | 51 | Atlanta Falcons | Falcons WR Sean Tennison | ||
| 2007 | X | 6/19/2005 | Seattle Seahawks | 9 | Atlanta Falcons | 21 | Atlanta Falcons | Falcons HB Thomas Jones | ||
| 2006 | IX | 11/13/2004 | New York Jets | 7 | Atlanta Falcons | 30 | Atlanta Falcons | Falcons HB Thomas Jones | ||
| 2005 | VIII | 4/17/2004 | Baltimore Colts | 10 | Atlanta Falcons | 24 | Atlanta Falcons | Falcons HB Thomas Jones | ||
| 2004 | VII | 9/7/2003 | Buffalo Bills | 0 | Atlanta Falcons | 45 | Atlanta Falcons | Falcons QB Todd Husak | ||
| 2003 | VI | 2/9/2003 | Tennessee Titans | 16 | Atlanta Falcons | 31 | Atlanta Falcons | Falcons WR Randy Moss | ||
| 2002 | V | 1/6/2002 | Kansas City Chiefs | 21 | Atlanta Falcons | 49 | Atlanta Falcons | Falcons WR Gary Parker | ||
| 2001 | IV | 12/10/2000 | Denver Broncos | 21 | Dallas Cowboys | 16 | Denver Broncos | Broncos LB John Mobley | ||
| 2000 | III | 6/4/2000 | Denver Broncos | 23 | Atlanta Falcons | 21 | Denver Broncos | Broncos HB Terrell Davis | ||
| 1999 | II | 11/21/1999 | New England Patriots | 28 | New York Giants | 31 | New York Giants | Giants QB Brad Johnson | ||
| 1998 | I | 5/23/1999 | Jacksonville Jaguars | 10 | Tampa Bay Bucs | 27 | Tampa Bay Bucs | Bucs QB Trent Dilfer | ||