PNFL

Should there be a QB controversy in LA? Posting for fun.

Herbert is 90 83 and Maxxed out in IN/DI. Williams is 89 81 and has 92 83 pots. 4 TCs will bring Williams to 92 83. If those points in IN/DI are not that consequential, consider starting Williams. Test it in games. before week 1.

I know all that. Just trying to have some extra fun. Going with Herbert is basically true to the NFL LA Chargers. He was ok last season for me. Caleb brings some extra excitement as the best QB prospect in the league in a while but basically forces me to ignore the risk of his low IN/DI.

I voted Herbert as I believe in doing everything to improve your odds to win, but this is also a game and you need to do what makes you happy and will be more fun for you. Managing a rookie through the season and adjusting as needed could be a fun challenge.

It's official. Justin Herbert will be the starting QB for the 2024 LA Chargers.

That's the right move. In fact you should never start Williams, you should never even play him. He's a collector's item and will be worth much more in the future if kept in mint condition and in his original packaging.