PNFL

Charlie released the rookie for the next draft. I looked back and graded/rated the rookies that made our rosters from the last draft:



Act column is weight ratings (using my weighting) as percentage of the same weighting of max ratings. The pot column is same but based on pots. The "Grade" columns is one based on actuals pone third, and potentials two thirds.

The weightings and calculations are based on what I will use to grade and rate the rookies in the upcoming draft.

So why is Atlanta ranked 12 for 2043 rookies? Because I did not draft players based on this criteria in the last draft.

Clearly Las Vegas scouted the rookies and drafted more effectively than the rest of us did.

Here it is again. Green is above average, blue is below average.

I think I only drafted one guy in like the 5th round to see if I could get the boost and ended up getting it. lol.

Is the far right column the number of players drafted? If so, I drafted 7 players, not 5.

Mitch-Chiefs wrote:Is the far right column the number of players drafted? If so, I drafted 7 players, not 5.

Yes... but look above it says the rookies that made the rosters. I think 2 of yours ended up in Seattle after mark did a little PS shopping.

Here is the ranking of teams by full roster using the same calculations. I may be the only one not surprised that Washington ranks first, above Chicago and the Jets.



Where Atlanta ranks shows that I need to improve as a GM.

You got S Snell and Mark got 2 CBs. I'd say my picks must have been valuable since you and Mark wanted them.

For those who may have forgotten, here are the post camp roster rankings I shared in the pre-season:

Your ranking has Kansas City ranked #1, and Atlanta ranked #17.

My ranking has Atlanta ranked #10 and Kansas City #4.

The team with the best overall roster in the PNFL, Washington, is ranked #1 on my ranking and #3 on yours.

Interesting.

Mitch-Chiefs wrote:For those who may have forgotten, here are the post camp roster rankings I shared in the pre-season:

The 8 playoff teams are ranked 1,2,3,6,8,8 (really 9),14, and 18 on your list.

On my list, the playoff teams ranked 1,2,4,6,8,11,14,and 17.

The biggest difference: you ranked Detroit 18 and I ranked them 6.

I ranked my own team 10, clearly it needs improvement, and your team 4. You ranked your own team 1 and my team 17.

Hmmmmmmmmmmmmmmm